Aug 30 2008
Freud and Hillman and Jung–oh my!
Did you ever pick up a book with blurbs from authors you love raving about the writer, only to finish the book and wonder, What the hell were they thinking?! and realize, they were talking about that author, but not that book? That might be this one. Or I might just be feeling ignorant and out of sorts. I just finished a new offering from Haven Kimmel, a novel called Iodine. Kimmel wrote A Girl Named Zippy (never got to it, but heard good things) and The Solace of Leaving Early (cover looks familiar, so..?), among others. This book, Iodine is about a college senior, Trace, who ran away from an abusive home and survived on her own, primarily by recreating herself. Much of her world is built on “carefully constructed delusion.” So, fine. I love a good mental illness. In the beginning, it’s a little difficult sifting the reality from the non-reality and the memories in the narrator’s journal and dream journal entries. Add to that, Trace is a psychology major who apparently has a remarkable memory for everything other than her own life, and the allusions begin to fly. Allusions to Jung, Hillman–Hillman is her favorite–and Freud. References to the allusions. Opinions about the references to the allusions. Some of the allusions were probably part of her delusions, but who knew? Waaaayyy too much to follow for me. Too many layers. Too many shrinks spoil the psychosis. I finished the book because I was curious to see how much of her past life would eventually be revealed, and because the writing was good, but I tap-danced through quite a bit. Something else that haunted me…Back when I first started this blog, I wrote about a book called Switching Time, a true account of a woman who had Multiple Personality Disorder, chronicled by her doctor. Some of the abuse described in Iodine sounds very similar to activities written about in Switching Time, although I had to finish the book and go back and compare notes to confirm it (I did learn that the book is being released in paperback shortly, FYI). It wouldn’t matter if Kimmel had read the same book, as I’m not aware of any rule that says when you borrow from real life it has to be your real life; it’s just one of those weird coincidences.
If you are a serious student of psychology, this could be a great time for your next book group. The rest of you: be warned!